Salary Comparison Calculator: Compare Two Job Offers
Compare two UK job offers side-by-side. Calculate exact net take-home differences, marginal tax on the pay rise, and true employer costs under 2026/27 HMRC rates.
Rates for the 2026/27 tax year, last reviewed 29 September 2026.
Net take-home difference
+£6,800 a year
That is an extra +£567 in your bank account every month.
- Gross salary difference +£10,000
- Extra Income Tax −£1,900
- Extra National Insurance −£800
- Extra Pension deduction −£500
- Net take-home gain +£6,800/yr
| Metric | Offer A | Offer B |
|---|---|---|
| Gross Annual | £40,000 | £50,000 |
| Net Monthly | £2,560 | £3,127 |
| Net Annual | £30,720 | £37,520 |
| Total Deductions | £9,280 | £12,480 |
| True Employer Cost | £46,450 | £58,250 |
Show the working: Side-by-side job offer comparison formulas
Gross Pay Increase = £50,000 − £40,000 = +£10,000/year (+£833/month)
Additional Tax = £10,000 × 20% = −£1,900/year (−£158/month)
Additional NI = £10,000 × 8% = −£800/year (−£67/month)
Additional Pension = £10,000 × 5% = −£500/year (−£42/month)
Net Take-Home Increase = +£6,800/year (+£567/month)
Common salary jump benchmarks in 2026/27
How much extra take-home pay you pocket across standard career transitions and promotions under UK tax brackets.
| Career Transition | Offer A | Offer B | Gross Rise | Net Gain (Annual) | Net Gain (Monthly) | Keep Rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Junior to Mid-Level | £28,000 | £35,000 | +£7,000 | +£4,760 | +£397/mo | 68% kept |
| Mid to Senior Promotion | £40,000 | £50,000 | +£10,000 | +£6,800 | +£567/mo | 68% kept |
| Crossing Higher Rate (£50,270) | £50,000 | £62,000 | +£12,000 | +£7,138 | +£595/mo | 59% kept |
| Senior to Lead Role | £70,000 | £85,000 | +£15,000 | +£8,250 | +£688/mo | 55% kept |
| The £100k Allowance Trap | £95,000 | £110,000 | +£15,000 | +£7,350 | +£613/mo | 49% kept |
Evaluating a job offer: Beyond headline gross pay
The marginal tax illusion
When an employer offers a £10,000 raise, psychology primes us to expect an extra £833 in our monthly bank account. In reality, under UK PAYE, every pound of that raise is taxed at your highest applicable tax band.
If the raise takes your earnings from £45,000 to £55,000, you cross the £50,270 higher-rate threshold. While earnings up to £50,270 are subject to 20% Income Tax and 8% National Insurance (28% combined), the earnings above £50,270 jump to 40% Income Tax and 2% National Insurance (42% combined).
The £100,000 personal allowance cliff edge
A career jump from £95,000 to £110,000 seems like a life-changing financial milestone. However, in the UK tax system, this lands squarely in the notorious £100k tax trap.
For every £2 you earn between £100,000 and £125,140, HMRC reduces your £12,570 tax-free personal allowance by £1. This creates an effective 60% income tax rate on top of 2% National Insurance. On a £15,000 raise from £95,000 to £110,000 (assuming an illustrative 5% auto-enrolment workplace pension contribution), you pocket +£7,350 net, keeping 49% and surrendering 51% to statutory deductions and pension.
Commuting and hidden work costs
A job offer that requires three days a week in Central London versus a fully remote position can easily wipe out a £6,000 pay rise. Commuting expenses—train season tickets, fuel, parking, and workday meals—are paid with post-tax pounds.
To pay for an annual £3,000 rail pass, a higher-rate taxpayer needs to earn over £5,170 in pre-tax gross salary just to break even.
How to compare two job offers: salary, pension and commute
The better headline salary is not always the better offer. Take-home pay, employer pension and travel costs all change the answer. Here is a worked example.
Salary versus pension: two offers with the same 5% employee contribution.
| Offer | Gross salary | Employer pension | Take-home (yearly) | Take-home (monthly) | Take-home + employer pension |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Offer A: higher salary | £42,000 | 3% (£1,260) | £32,080 | £2,673 | £33,340 |
| Offer B: better pension | £40,000 | 8% (£3,200) | £30,720 | £2,560 | £33,920 |
For a full breakdown of either salary, open the £40,000 after tax or £50,000 after tax page.
Frequently asked questions about salary comparison
How much of a £10,000 pay rise do I actually keep in the UK?
It depends on your current tax bracket. Moving from £30,000 to £40,000 pays 20% Income Tax and 8% NI on the increase, keeping £7,200 (72%). Moving from £60,000 to £70,000 pays 40% Income Tax and 2% NI, keeping £5,800 (58%). Moving from £100,000 to £110,000 triggers the Personal Allowance taper (60% tax + 2% NI), leaving £3,800 (38%). Figures assume 0% pension; workplace pension deductions apply proportionally.
Why does my second job offer feel like less take-home than expected?
When evaluating a higher salary offer, you only pay basic rate or higher rate tax on the delta. However, other factors also scale with gross pay: auto-enrolment workplace pension deductions (e.g. 5%), student loan repayments (9% above threshold), and higher Employer National Insurance costs that some companies offset in overall package bonuses.
How does pension salary sacrifice affect salary comparison?
Salary sacrifice reduces your contractual gross pay before tax and NI. If Job Offer B offers a salary sacrifice pension arrangement, both you and the employer save National Insurance. Sacrificing a pay rise into your pension allows you to keep 100% of the funds in your retirement pot rather than surrendering 28% to 62% in immediate taxes.
How do student loan repayments change when changing jobs for higher pay?
Student loan repayments are levied strictly on earnings above the plan threshold (e.g. £29,385 for Plan 2). If your current salary is already above this threshold, every single pound of your new job's pay rise incurs an extra 9% deduction. For a higher-rate earner, this turns a nominal 42% marginal rate into 51%.
Does Scotland's tax system make a difference when comparing job offers?
Yes. Scotland has 6 income tax bands compared to 3 in England and Wales. The Higher Rate of 42% begins at £43,662 in Scotland, compared to £50,270 in England. Additionally, Scotland has an Advanced Rate of 45% starting at £75,000. When comparing an offer across borders, take-home pay can vary by several thousand pounds.
How do I factor in commuting costs when comparing two job offers?
Commuting costs must be paid out of post-tax net income. If Job B offers £5,000 more gross, you might keep roughly £2,900 net. If Job B requires £250/month in train fares or fuel (£3,000/year post-tax), you will actually be financially worse off despite a higher headline gross salary.
What is the true cost of an employee to a UK employer in 2026/27?
In 2026/27, employers pay secondary Class 1 National Insurance at 15.0% on earnings above £5,000, plus a statutory minimum 3% pension contribution. When comparing offers, companies with generous non-taxable perks (such as enhanced pension matching of 8–10%) can offer far superior total compensation than companies offering slightly higher cash gross.
How does crossing £60,000 impact Child Benefit when taking a new job?
The High Income Child Benefit Charge (HICBC) claws back 1% of your Child Benefit for every £200 earned between £60,000 and £80,000. If taking a higher-paying job pushes your Adjusted Net Income into this bracket, your household could lose up to £2,212 in Child Benefit annually unless you offset it with pension contributions.
How do I compare two job offers in the UK?
Compare take-home pay rather than gross salary, then adjust for everything that changes with the job: pension, commute, bonus and student loan. Enter both salaries in the calculator above to see the monthly difference. As an example, moving from £40,000 to £45,000 adds £3,400 a year after tax, NI and a 5% pension.
Is a higher salary or a better employer pension worth more?
Compare cash and pension together. With 5% employee pension on both, £42,000 with a 3% employer contribution gives £32,080 take-home a year, while £40,000 with 8% gives £30,720. The extra £1,360 of cash on Offer A compares with £1,940 more going into your pension on Offer B. The pension money is locked away until retirement but is not taxed on the way in, so it depends how much you need now. The salary sacrifice calculator shows how much more a pension contribution is worth.
Is a pay rise worth it after a longer commute?
Only the extra take-home counts, because commuting is paid from net pay. A move from £40,000 to £45,000 adds £3,400 after deductions; a £250 monthly commute costs £3,000 a year, leaving £400 real gain. Use the net to gross calculator to find the salary needed to cover a cost.
Explore related salary and tax tools
- UK Salary Calculator Official take-home pay calculator with tax code, overtime, and benefits.
- Hourly to salary calculator Convert hourly rates to annual, monthly, and weekly take-home pay.
- Second job tax calculator Calculate PAYE deductions and National Insurance across two jobs.
- Salary sacrifice calculator See how pension salary sacrifice increases pension wealth and lowers tax.
- £35,000 salary after tax Detailed analysis of a £35,000 salary, tax bands, and monthly budget.
- £45,000 salary after tax Take-home pay and basic rate tax deductions on a £45,000 wage.
- £55,000 salary after tax Take-home pay entering the 40% higher rate tax threshold.
- £75,000 salary after tax Mid-tier professional take-home pay and tax deductions breakdown.
- £100,000 salary after tax Take-home pay and personal allowance taper analysis at £100k.
Sources: Income Tax Act 2007, Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992, Finance Act 2025. Reviewed 29 September 2026 under our Editorial & Verification Policy.